[ad_pod ]

In the last few days a report from the BBC has detailed that West Ham United are interested in Fenerbahce captain and Turkey left-back Hasan Ali Kaldirim.

If the rumour is true, Manuel Pellegrini is undoubtedly trying to solve his team’s dilemma at left-back once and for all with the signing of a high-quality international.

For three seasons now, the first-choice left-back baton has been passed constantly between Arthur Masuaku and Aaron Cresswell in east London, with neither of them able to hold it permanently.

Masuaku was the man in possession at the conclusion of the 2018/2019 campaign, though that was only because of an injury to Cresswell, something which has been a common theme. The ex-England man is the better option but way too injury-prone.

Adding someone with the quality to make the spot their own would allow the Hammers to get rid of one of the underperforming duo and settle the debate for good.

In light of this, three Football FanCast writers give their verdicts on whether West Ham should sign Kaldirim…

Charles Jones

“I’m not sure that’s the type of deal West Ham should be pursuing. Ali Kaldirim isn’t a clear upgrade on Cresswell and Masuaku at left-back. Historically, imports from the Turkish league haven’t fared too well in the Premier League, and with Fenerbahce having their joint-worst season in 30 years any club should steer clear of signing players from the Istanbul outfit.”

Harry Sherlock

“No. West Ham have two perfectly suitable left-backs in Cresswell and Masuaku and there is little point pursuing another one, as they’d surely have to cash in on one of the two they already have. Indeed, there are a number of other pressing issues that need addressing; West Ham need at least one striker, a couple of midfielders and potentially a centre-back too. Signing a left-back simply makes no sense, regardless of how good Ali Kaldirim may be.”

Jack Saville

“Ali Kaldirim has proven to be a genuine threat from full-back this season by scoring three goals and providing five assists in all competitions, but his lack of experience in the Premier League is a serious worry. West Ham have lacked a cutting edge on the overlap and it’s a problem that needs addressing, but I don’t think this is the answer. Pellegrini should turn his attention towards an alternative target to strengthen at full-back.”